I had no idea what to do, so I went back to my cart, even though I KNEW the toys would all fall out... I thought they'd show up by now, but maybe it'll take longer. Hoping not 30 mins.
So annoying.

Edit: lol, I guess they did not fall out after all? I had a small amount of credit, which I guess was applied, making the toys "partially paid" and going into my order history. I now need to pay the remainder to complete my order. Interesting, and I'm happy, but would have been nice to receive some sort of notification instead of waiting around.